Skip to main content

Seattle is more affordable than Detroit? How’s that even possible?

The median monthly rent for a one-bedroom apartment in Seattle is nearly $2,000, while the median rent for the same apartment type in Detroit is $780. So, Detroit is clearly the more affordable market, right?

Wrong.

A new study by Rent.com released Friday reveals that determining rent affordability is far more complicated than simply examining rental rates. The median annual income plays a large part in affordability, thus why Seattle, with it’s $2,000 per month median rent, is more affordable than the Motor City.

In Detroit, the average worker earns about $22,000 post-tax, which means that housing costs account for a whopping 42 percent of their monthly expenses — 12 percent more than the affordability threshold of 30 percent.

Meanwhile, in Seattle, the average worker has a net income of $63,600, which means housing costs account for 38 percent of monthly expenses. That’s still above the affordability threshold, but 4 percent more affordable than Detroit.

“The same Detroit that just a few years ago filed for bankruptcy is a less affordable place to live than Seattle – home of Starbucks and Amazon?” wrote Brian Carberry, the author of a report that accompanies the Rent.com study. “You better believe it.”

Fend off competition from new brokerage models

Take a page from their technology playbook READ MORE

New York City clocked in as the least affordable city, with rent accounting for an ungodly 121 percent of a city dweller’s paycheck and the average one-bedroom apartment hovering around $4,365, according to the report. Boston, Los Angeles, San Francisco and Philadelphia rounded out the top five least affordable metropolitan areas while the Texas cities of El Paso, Fort Worth and Austin were named the most affordable rental markets overall.

“In New York, you’ll need to pay 121 percent of your income just to afford your rent,” wrote Carberry. “So unless you have a lucrative side hustle, you’re stuck in a less-than-desirable place in the outer boroughs or Jersey.

The affordability ranking for the 25 largest metros in the U.S.

Renters in Los Angeles, San Francisco, Washington D.C. and Philadelphia are in a similar situation, according to the report. While none of these markets are cheap, San Francisco and Washington D.C. are more affordable than their neighbors, Los Angeles and Philadelphia.

In San Francisco, the median rent for a one-bedroom apartment is $3,663, $1,223 more than the median rent in Los Angeles ($2,440). But with an average net income of $40,342, the average worker in Los Angeles will spend 73 percent of their budget on housing costs. On the other hand, San Franciscans who have an average net income of $69,321 will spend 63 percent of their budget on housing costs.

The trend continues in a comparison between Washington D.C. and Philadelphia. The median rent in Philadelphia is cheaper ($1,320) than Washington D.C. ($2,095), but workers in the City of Brotherly Love have an average net income that’s $20,534 less than what Washingtonians make ($53,175).

That difference in income means Philadelphians spend 49 percent of their income on housing costs, while workers in Washington D.C. spent 47 percent.

On the extremes are New York City and El Paso, Texas. New York City is the most expensive market for renters, with the average worker making a net income of $43,230 spending 121 percent of their income on a median-priced one-bedroom apartment ($4,364).

El Paso, however, is the most affordable market for renters. A worker making a median net income of $35,266 will only spend 21 percent of their income on a median-priced apartment ($621) in the area.

Methodology

Rent.com took the median household income from the U.S. Census Bureau for the 25 most populated cities in the country and used an ADP salary paycheck calculator to determine the median net income with standard withholdings and no deductions. They then compared this figure to RentPath data of median rental rates for a one-bedroom property in each specific city to determine the percentage of your median monthly pay that will go towards the minimum median rent.

Email Marian McPherson.


Seattle is more affordable than Detroit? How’s that even possible? curated from Inman

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Vacation rental company Vacasa buys Sterling Resorts

Vacation rental management tech startup  Vacasa  isn’t slowing down its ambitions to conquer the market: this week, it announced that it has purchased Sterling Resorts, a vacation management company on Florida’s Gulf Coast. Sterling has changed hands before: it was  bought by Pacifica Companies in 2015 and currently manages 450 homes. Now it will become a part of Vacasa’s effort to expand its presence in vacation destinations such as northern Florida, where Sterling is based. At the time of this latest purchase, Sterling’s home inventory was  down from 585 properties in 2015. Vacasa has raised more than $200 million since its launch ten years ago. Founder Eric Breon said he was motivated to start the company after struggling to find a satisfactory management solution for a cabin belonging to his wife’s family on the Washington coast. Now Vacasa seeks to provide rental property owners with “a seamless experience…through innovative technology and local staf...
Post a Comment
Read more

In An Era Of WeWork, Co-Working Space NeueHouse Sits Above The Fray

NeueHouse CEO Josh Wyatt Seuss Moments In today’s cluttered co-working landscape, it can be hard for companies to makes themselves heard over the din. Elevated co-working space  NeueHouse  wants to create an unparalleled experience for creatives through elevated programming and outstanding design. NeueHouse describes itself as “ a private cultural and collaborative space for prominent creatives, artists and entrepreneurs,” with current locations in Los Angeles and New York. In November, following an announcement of $30 million in funding , the company announced Josh Wyatt as its new CEO. Wyatt is a veteran of the hospitality industry, having co-founded Generator  in 2007, a chain of culture-focused hostels targeted at millennials, before moving on to Equinox to head the fitness brand’s hotel developments in New York City. Forbes interviewed Wyatt to talk about creativity, design, the gun threat incident at NeueHouse New York, and why he i...
Post a Comment
Read more

Could Ken Griffin's Penthouse Purchase Cost NYC Real Estate Buyers Millions?

'The Billionaire's Bunker' at 220 Central Park South is pictured on January 24, 2019, in New York - Hedge fund billionaire Ken Griffin has completed the purchase of a four-story penthouse in the building for $238 millionm- the most ever paid for a home in the US. The building is a residential skyscraper that is currently under construction. (Photo credit: TIMOTHY A. CLARY/AFP/Getty Images) Getty A 2014 bill that aims to impose an additional tax on part-time New York residents—dubbed the “pied-a-terre tax”—has risen from the dead, largely in thanks to the recent record-breaking Central Park penthouse purchase by billionaire Ken Griffin. Griffin, worth an estimated $11.7 billion and No. 45 on the Forbes 400 , reportedly bought the $238 million-dollar apartment “as a place to stay when he’s in town,” according to his representatives. The purchase drew widespread attention to the financial losses that part-time and foreign property owners can cause the city. Bec...
Post a Comment
Read more